Are You Reacting or Responding? Defensiveness in Relationships.
Ethan’s a lovely guy. Kind-hearted. Generous. But ask him a simple question like, “Did you leave this glass here?” and suddenly, he’s defending his entire life choices as though he’s on trial. By the end of the conversation, you’re wondering if asking about a glass was code for something in an alternate universe you’re not privy to. If this sounds familiar, whether you’re an Ethan or live with one, welcome to the complicated world of impulsivity and defensiveness in relationships.
Let’s dive into what’s really happening, why it happens (yes, there is science behind Ethan’s freak-out), and most importantly, how we can all grow past it. Spoiler: it’s not by flinging “You’re always lying” accusations faster than a toddler with spaghetti.
What Are Impulsivity and Defensiveness in Relationships?
Impulsivity is like when your brain jumps off the high dive without checking if there’s water in the pool. It’s classic in ADHD but also shows up in PTSD, BPD, Autism, and your average stressed-out neurotypical (yes, even the most calm-looking people can have their moments). It often looks like interrupting, blurting out, or making split-second decisions faster than a Black Friday bargain hunter.
Defensiveness, on the other hand, is impulsivity’s overthinking cousin. It’s what happens when someone feels criticised or attacked (whether real or imagined) and instinctively shields themselves. This might involve deflecting, counterattacking, or shutting down entirely. You know, the “Why do you hate me?” after you simply asked, “Do you want tea?” situation.
Why Does Defensiveness Happen in Relationships?
Defensiveness can appear for all sorts of reasons, turning a simple chat into a courtroom drama. It might stem from feeling criticised, fearing rejection, carrying emotional baggage, or just being utterly stressed and tired. For neurodivergent folks, factors like sensory overload, emotional regulation challenges, or a unique way of processing emotions can add an extra layer of intensity to interactions.
At the core of many defensive reactions lies Rejection Sensitivity Dysphoria (RSD), which is an intense emotional response to perceived criticism or rejection. Common among people with ADHD, Autism, and BPD, RSD means even a minor comment like, “Did you leave this glass here?” can feel like, “Why are you so careless?” The sting of perceived judgment leads to defensive behaviour, not out of pettiness but as a protective reflex.
Understanding these triggers, whether neurodivergent or not, helps us approach those moments with empathy rather than frustration.
ADHD
- Emotional dysregulation and poor executive functioning can also be the culprits here. ADHD brains tend to hit “react” before “pause.” This isn’t laziness or carelessness; it’s how their brain’s wiring operates. Ferrari engines with scooter brakes, anyone?
BPD
- Besides RSD, fear of abandonment and intense emotional shifts often amplifies defensiveness. These emotions can lead to reactions that feel disproportionate but reflect the emotional turbulence beneath the surface. It’s not just “You left this glass out”; it’s “You’re rejecting me as a person and I’m about to spiral into despair or fury.”
Autism
- Misinterpretations in social communication can sometimes lead to defensiveness in relationships, especially when someone feels unfairly judged. Different ways of perceiving the world and communicating can create misunderstandings that escalate tension. If Ethan’s having a sensory overload day, it’s easier for small comments to feel like big critiques.
PTSD
- Trauma creates a hypersensitivity to perceived criticism, activating fight-or-flight mode faster than you can say, “I only asked about the glass.”
Neurotypical
- Even NTs (neurotypicals) can get defensive or impulsive, especially when overwhelmed, hungry, or sleep-deprived. We’re only human… unless we’re also hangry, in which case all bets are off.
How Defensiveness in Relationships Affects People
For Ethan
- When your first response is to deflect, lie, or counterattack, you might feel like you’re protecting yourself. But in reality, you’re creating an environment where trust and safety erode. People stop asking questions. They stop engaging. And eventually, they might stop trying altogether. If you find yourself alone, then maybe take a step back and rethink your approach.
For Ethan’s Loved Ones
- Living with impulsivity and defensiveness can be exhausting. It can feel like you’re walking on eggshells, trying to avoid triggering a blow-up or a shutdown. When Ethan accuses you of spying on his WhatsApp after you asked about the weather, it’s easy to throw up your hands and wonder if communication is even worth it. (Spoiler: It is. Thoughtful communication, combined with clear boundaries, can break the cycle and foster understanding.)
Tools for Growth
For Ethan
- Pause Before Reacting: This sounds so simple, doesn’t it? But practicing the 5-second rule (or even 3) can work wonders. Take a breath and ask yourself, “Am I being attacked, or does it just feel that way?” Spoiler: 80% of the time, it’s the latter.
- Try the 5-Minute Rule (for when 5 seconds aren’t enough): A few seconds just aren’t enough to reset. Enter the 5-Minute Rule. This is a mini time-out from the conversation to let your emotions settle. Step away, grab a snack, or just chill for a bit. This short break can help you cool down and return without turning into a human volcano.
- Practice Emotional Awareness: Keep a journal or use a feelings wheel to name what you’re feeling. “I feel embarrassed” is easier to work through than “You hate me and I’m going to war.”
- Seek Therapy: CBT (Cognitive Behavioural Therapy), DBT (Dialectical Behaviour Therapy), mindfulness training, or even Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) can help you rewire those knee-jerk responses.
- Focus on Sleep and Routine: Better sleep and regular routines can significantly reduce emotional reactivity. A well-rested brain is less likely to snap.
- Mindfulness Practices: Daily meditation, guided breathing exercises, or even yoga can help train your brain to slow down before reacting.
For Loved Ones
- Don’t Escalate: Respond calmly and avoid accusations. Instead of “Why are you lying?” try, “That’s not what I meant; let me clarify.”
- Set Boundaries: If the conversation spirals into defensiveness or attacks, calmly end it. “I’m happy to talk when we’re both calm” is a powerful phrase.
- Model Honesty and Calmness: Your steady response can encourage Ethan to reflect. “I’m not attacking you. I just wanted to understand…” goes a long way.
- Support Healthy Habits: Encourage regular sleep, mindfulness, and routines that promote emotional regulation.
The Hard Truth
Defensiveness and impulsivity push people away. They create barriers to connection and leave everyone involved feeling misunderstood and frustrated.
For Ethan
- If you’re constantly feeling attacked, take a moment to reflect. Are you being pushed away because people are unfair, or because you’re reacting in ways that make connection difficult?
For Loved Ones
- Remember, it’s okay to set boundaries. You’re not responsible for Ethan’s reactions, but you can choose how much of your energy you give.
Ending on Hope
Impulsivity and defensiveness don’t have to define anyone’s relationships. With patience, practice, and maybe a little humour, Ethan (and the rest of us) can learn to respond thoughtfully instead of reacting impulsively. It’s not about perfection, rather it’s about progress. And trust me, even one pause before reacting can make the world of difference.
Community Promo
We hope this article resonated with you. If you’re looking for more insights, tips, and a supportive community, join us at Herbal Biohacker. Together, we’re exploring the intersection of neurodivergence, personal growth, and holistic wellness.
